Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Mrs Warbouys]

If my car was balancing over the edge of a cliff I wouldn't get a learner driver to move it.

[Jimmy]

[quote author=Jacque link=topic=22453.msg264789#msg264789

Thirdly, and most pivotally, if MD goes, would you really trust GR to find a suitable replacement? Well agree with not trusting Rowley to find a decent replacement however Buzz not upto the job

 



[/quote]

[Jacque]

[quote author=Jacque link=topic=22453.msg264789#msg264789

Thirdly, and most pivotally, if MD goes, would you really trust GR to find a suitable replacement? Well agree with not trusting Rowley to find a decent replacement however Buzz not upto the job

 

But wouldn't you agree that the rut Altrincham was by December, would've made the job extremely tough for any manager - near enough impossible? What would define as a 'good job' from a manager from that point onward? Ten wins? Five wins? Or three wins and several draws like MD?

[/quote]

[Alty Bri]

I actually agree with much of Jacque's logic and fair play for coming onto this forum to explain.

[im not really here]

Stability is important but the Club have initiated a recruitment process. If he is the best candidate that has applied then we really do have problems.

[Jimmy]

[quote author=Jacque link=topic=22453.msg264789#msg264789

Thirdly, and most pivotally, if MD goes, would you really trust GR to find a suitable replacement? Well agree with not trusting Rowley to find a decent replacement however Buzz not upto the job

 

But wouldn't you agree that the rut Altrincham was by December, would've made the job extremely tough for any manager - near enough impossible? What would define as a 'good job' from a manager from that point onward? Ten wins? Five wins? Or three wins and several draws like MD?Jacque has now been involved partly in the last 2 relegations,I'm not to concerned by the manager the problems higher up

[/quote]

[Jimmy]

Unless I've missed something, the last former Alty full back to manage us was Stan Allan.

Let's hope lightning indeed does not strike twice in the same place....

to be fair to Stan he did a very good job at Witton to get the job unlike Buzz

[taxi Phil]

Unless I've missed something, the last former Alty full back to manage us was Stan Allan.

Let's hope lightning indeed does not strike twice in the same place....

to be fair to Stan he did a very good job at Witton to get the job unlike Buzz

If you're going to be THAT fair Jimmy, Young did a good job at Chester, as did Harvey at Forest Green.

[Jimmy]

Yes however Phil Stan's good job at Witton was his previous job i thought at the time that his appointment wasn't that bad under the circumstances obviously he was out of his depth when he got the gig

[Hugo]

Hi there,

I’m the guy behind the article yesterday on jactal Wordpress.

Just thought I’d clear some bits up.

I was sat in the main standout beside the dug-out at Curzon. Right after the match, I thought I heard the crowd quiet loudly chant ‘Doughty Stay’ as he was walking over to them applauding.
Several people who were in the crowd have wrote on this forum said that this wasn’t true – or at least they didn’t hear it, and so for that I will take back what I wrote, and say ‘yes’ an error on my part.

I would never make stuff up, though – that I do take issue with.

Everything else that people have  said about article on the forum, I don’t have a problem with. You are, of course, well in your right to say it.

My point re: ‘Doughty to stay is down to a couple of elements.

Firstly, a sixth roll of the dice would do more harm than good considering the team have finally started picking points here and there. However little that may be. 

Secondly, I think MD has brought the players together, got them working hard. That’s not to say I think MD could take you back to NL, but, for now, he’s a core of stability, and that’s very important in the current climate of Altrincham.

Thirdly, and most pivotally, if MD goes, would you really trust GR to find a suitable replacement? He’s tried five times before and look at the mess it’s got the club in. If you trust his judgement then fine, but if you don’t, I’d ask why you would MD out, in order for GR to source another one?

Best,

Jacque

GR appointed Sinnot and that was a very good appointment. We would be playing national league football this season if he hadn't left when he did

[andrewflynn]

Did all fans process their Chanting Licence in time for today's game?

[Jimmy]

Hi there,

I’m the guy behind the article yesterday on jactal Wordpress.

Just thought I’d clear some bits up.

I was sat in the main standout beside the dug-out at Curzon. Right after the match, I thought I heard the crowd quiet loudly chant ‘Doughty Stay’ as he was walking over to them applauding.
Several people who were in the crowd have wrote on this forum said that this wasn’t true – or at least they didn’t hear it, and so for that I will take back what I wrote, and say ‘yes’ an error on my part.

I would never make stuff up, though – that I do take issue with.

Everything else that people have  said about article on the forum, I don’t have a problem with. You are, of course, well in your right to say it.

My point re: ‘Doughty to stay is down to a couple of elements.

Firstly, a sixth roll of the dice would do more harm than good considering the team have finally started picking points here and there. However little that may be. 

Secondly, I think MD has brought the players together, got them working hard. That’s not to say I think MD could take you back to NL, but, for now, he’s a core of stability, and that’s very important in the current climate of Altrincham.

Thirdly, and most pivotally, if MD goes, would you really trust GR to find a suitable replacement? He’s tried five times before and look at the mess it’s got the club in. If you trust his judgement then fine, but if you don’t, I’d ask why you would MD out, in order for GR to source another one?

Best,

Jacque

GR appointed Sinnot and that was a very good appointment. We would be playing national league football this season if he hadn't left when he did

we were going down anyway Sinnott was a fair appointment but by no means a very good one history will look kind on him because of what's happened since

[taxi Phil]

On a scale from 1-10 where 1 is Neil Young and 10 is Tony Sanders, Sinnott was at best a 6.

[Jimmy]

Spot on Phil

[York Alty is back]

On a scale from 1-10 where 1 is Neil Young and 10 is Tony Sanders, Sinnott was at best a 6.

personally I give Lee 7 but each to their own view.

The important thing now is to find and appoint a 10, or failing the impossible a 9.