www.altyfans.co.uk
General Category => Altrincham FC First Team => Topic started by: Alty TV on November 25, 2018, 01:12:32 PM
-
Extended and embargo-free highlights from Altrincham Vs Bradford (Park Avenue):
https://youtu.be/a6VST4rJ1VE
-
Excellent
Jury out for me on the penalty and first Bradford booking
-
Not a penalty for me I'm afraid - but just goes to show when things are going well for you...
-
Not a penalty for me I'm afraid - but just goes to show when things are going well for you...
Totally agree that it was at the least a harsh decision, but it's the sort of thing that happened to us a fair bit while we were spiralling downwards, and what goes around comes around.
-
Very good highlights, very harsh penalty decision, very comprehensive victory.
-
the guy sticks his left leg out to the side and catches jordan hulme with his knee.
-
I didn't think it was a penalty on the day and I don't think it's one now. A stroke of luck for us, though overall 2-0 at half-time was about right.
-
not a penalty because there was no trip or not a penalty because jordan might have stayed on his feet?
-
The defender hardly makes any sort of challenge and if there is contact, it's Hulme running into him. It's also telling that the crowd doesn't appeal when Hulme goes down and nor do any of the Alty players in shot, apart from Richman half-heartedly.
-
It’s a bit harsh but the BPA lad waves his leg at Hulme and you are asking for trouble doing that, also although the Ref is not in shot he appears very quickly from right behind and will have had a very good view.
It’s not cricket btw, you don’t have to appeal.
-
Just as a matter of interest, the goal of Josh Hancock's was the culmination of a 22-pass move before Hancock scored. BPA did not touch the ball at any stage of the build-up.
-
My thought at the time was it was never a penalty, nothing I’ve seen or heard since has persuaded me otherwise. I wouldn’t say Jordan dived ( he didn’t), but he certainly threw himself forward off the ground before any contact was made. I’d also agree that the contact seemed minimal, however we’ve had plenty given against us over the last few seasons that were dodgy decisions. There was an absolutely blatant handball in the York game the week before not given as a penalty for us....so this one makes up for it.