Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ripleym]

This isn't the greatest picture, as it is bang out of focus, but thought I would ask the question anyway: is this inside or outside the box?

[Baldrick]

In

[Hamilton]

You have to give the 'keeper the benefit of the doubt on this one. Great photo though!

[AltyTunnelSteward]

For once in my life I was bang in line (Wish i could do it more often when an Assistant Referee) and the answer is that he was clearly inside the box when the contact was made.

Also the contact was with his chest which, tbh makes where he was a little less relevant

[Nom de plume]

Also the contact was with his chest which, tbh makes where he was a little less relevant

I never spotted that he was deformed with a chest on the end of his wrist. Poor sod....

[Jezza]

I wasn't there but judging from ATS' clear evidence it was clearly outside the box and a clear handball....

Actually can I retract that?.....I've just studied the photo again in conjunction with my special referee's lens and the keeper is actually on his goal line... and actually he heads the ball anyway....actually....

[Hamilton]

For once in my life I was bang in line (Wish i could do it more often when an Assistant Referee) and the answer is that he was clearly inside the box when the contact was made.

Also the contact was with his chest which, tbh makes where he was a little less relevant

With his chest my ar$e!

Which must be some deflection as I'm miles away!

[Jezza]

I am more inclined to agree the ball hit Hamilton's arse than it hitting the keepers chest.....

[bighairedmike]

It was definitely handled, (the ball, I am casting no aspersions on Mr Hamiltons rear) tabs it looked out to me, both in the photo and in real time.

[Hamilton]

It was definitely handled, (the ball, I am casting no aspersions on Mr Hamiltons rear) tabs it looked out to me, both in the photo and in real time.

I should be so lucky!