Under 1973 regulations, the Buxton pitch was playable......but the Sheffield based referee apparently inspected it accompanied by his son. The young man said "If it snows again, we're not going to make it home tonight."
Thus was the match postponed.......and I cadged a lift home on the team coach.
Phil, I didn't see the pitch, therefore cannot comment, but 2 things happened that day that I have not experienced....before or since.... that indicated to me that it probably was unplayable:-
1) The Kick Off was brought forward the day before to 2pm because even then they were 100% certain that the pitch would be unplayable by 4pm.
2) As I got off the 'Alty Supporters Train' at Buxton station around 2.10pm (the kick off time may have changed but the train time didn't), my fear for the game being postponed was heightened, on exiting the station, by the sight of an individual skiing down the high street!
January 20th 1973.....my 3rd Alty away game & we haven't had a supporters train to an FA Trophy match since, to my knowledge?
I didn't see the replay, when I believe Peter Frankish had a nightmare in goal & our kid (who was 9 at the time) & I also grabbed a lift back on the team coach & then went to watch the team training at Moss Lane.