I can only assume it depends where you watched the game from (mausoleum for me). I thought he was ok 2nd half with a reasonable touch and some good 1st half crosses. Prob looked overhit cos McCarthy ducked under or shied away from most of them. Defensively, esp what i saw at close hand first half he absolutely scared me to death, turning his back on crosses (like Darlo's equaliser), hopelessy diving in on Edwards as he skipped round him, giving away what should have been a penalty when he climbed all over Walker. The man is a car crash of a footballer, an accident waiting to happen. And i've just seen a clip of his hesitancy for Kiddy's first goal. Still, he must have something going for him and he did appear to do a bit better second half.