It's all about opinions, but those who went to the Chester game should remember how well Charlton played at left back, indeed there were several posts on here to that affect. I'd give him more time, and not bin him on the basis of an iffy game at Trafford ( he was not on his own that night ) and the games against United and Crewe who had players against him who are far superior to what he'll face in the league.
We need to give these lads a chance to bed in, rather than be so reactive to less than perfect performances every game.
Congrats to NY for bringing in Hannigan and Cyrus...looks a really solid pair. Lynch and Patterson have also done very well, added to Goodall and things are shaping up well.