We've been terrible against the teams around us, when it has mattered the most. It is as simple as that. That isn't even an opinion, it is a fact. Here's a head-to-head mini league of the top five:
(Team, played, won, drawn, lost, for, against, GD, points.)
AFC Telfor 8 4 3 1 20 17 +3 15
Hednesfor 8 4 2 2 19 15 +4 14
North Ferri 8 3 2 3 11 10 +1 11
Guiseley 8 3 1 4 18 18 0 10
Altrincham 8 1 4 3 12 14 -2 7
Its also the reason I'm not very optimistic for the play offs. A marginally better record in this department and the league would have been ours. As it is, we have failed to win key games - most notably for me the 1-1 draws with AFC Telford and North Ferriby. Two extra points on one of those teams would have become huge.