www.altyfans.co.uk
General Category => Altrincham FC First Team => Topic started by: im not really here on January 26, 2013, 02:59:46 PM
-
Jordan Sinnott is in Hudersfield's starting 11 at home to Leicester City in the FA Cup today. Interesting to see and hear how he does.
-
He was sh*t for us
-
Is he playing in his natural position or has he been shunted onto the right wing in favour of somebody better?
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
-
whether he was rubbish for us (my opinion in the two games I saw) or merely quite good (other's opinion) he certainly was not the different class in BSN you would expect to see from a player capable of starting an FA Cup 4th round tie between two Championship teams!
-
In fairness, Huddersfield haven't got a manager.
-
Jordan Sinnott is in Hudersfield's starting 11 at home to Leicester City in the FA Cup today. Interesting to see and hear how he does.
Substituted after 66 minutes.
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Phil,
Jordan Sinnott may go on to achieve great things in the game and, then again, he may not.
Judged purely on the four of his total of six appearances (in which he was substituted on four occasions) for Alty that I witnessed, I have to say that I was distinctly underwhelmed.
I expected a lot more of him, to be honest.
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Oh so when a player plays out of position he is doing you a favour
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Oh so when a player plays out of position he is doing you a favour
did we not pay him ? He was only doing us a favour
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Oh so when a player plays out of position he is doing you a favour
To be honest, in his position yes.
He came to us to get some game time - every game he played was watched by representatives of Huddersfield where he is a Central Midfield Player. Playing wide on the right as he did he clearly is not going to be as comfortable / effective as he would be in the middle. This, as has been stated was obvious on more than one occasion
So, to summarise, in order to do us a favour, he compromised his potential performance levels in front of his "bosses"
-
In the words of the sadly departed Gary Coleman what you talking about
-
Oh dear!
If you cannot understand the implications on an aspiring professional's career of the scenario I have described then I really don't want to waste key strokes on an explanation
-
He could hardly refuse to play there that would do his future a lot of good wrong position or not in my opinion his commitment was not quite good enough so I don't think he did us much of a favour
-
He probably learned a lot more playing for Alty than playing in academy football. Maybe Huddersfield may offer to sent more of their decent youth players to help us out and help educate them football wise.
-
I'd rather take a risk on a player from our leauge or leauge below for us it seems for every Ryan shotton there are 10 who lack the commitment Greg Tansey and Ben Williams have had very good careers but even they were awfull
-
He played quite often out of position to do us a favour. When he played where he was supposed to he looked more than okay
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Phil he was garbage
Most certainly didn't do us any favours,
Why do you always defend sh*t? sh*t players, sh*t refs your always the first to defend?
-
Whilst I wouldn't quite go so far as to call him garbage, he certainly didn't pull up many trees. I thought he played very well for the first 70 minutes at Brackley before running out of steam, but otherwise I'd only mark him 5 out of 10.
What the Huddersfield contingent should have learned is that Jordan is far from the finished product, and they should now know which areas of his game need working on (I'd suggest his passing as a priority !). If they take that learning curve as a positive, then they may well see benefits in loaning young players out in the future.
-
I thought he got a rough time because-
a-he was the manager's son
b-he was played out of his best position.
For what its worth i think he's a decent footballer
-
I enjoy point A Stockport I'm sure if Jorge messi was our manager we would give his son grief if he was on loan for us
-
Obviously though Mount Street knows better than the Huddersfield Manager who will see him every day in training
Pointless comment. You're comparing two different things.
-
I thought he got a rough time because-
a-he was the manager's son
b-he was played out of his best position.
For what its worth i think he's a decent footballer
I fancy your right with those 3 statements matey
-
I thought he was ok but a loan player should be good enough to improve your first 11 not your squad
-
I thought he was ok but a loan player should be good enough to improve your first 11 not your squad
This. 100%.
-
So who is going to play in the number 7 shirt on Tuesday? Sean Densmore was
Terrible, and Scott leather was very uneasy against Hinckley.
Sinnott was not that bad.
-
What were our results when he started-did they improve? Thats surely the acid test.
-
I thought Sinnott did well for us. HOWEVER in front of goal he left a lot to be desired.
I certainly wouldnt be dissapointed if he was loaned out to us again.
-
Oh dear!
If you cannot understand the implications on an aspiring professional's career of the scenario I have described then I really don't want to waste key strokes on an explanation
Different ones, since we're talking about Gary Coleman?
-
So who is going to play in the number 7 shirt on Tuesday? Sean Densmore was
Terrible, and Scott leather was very uneasy against Hinckley.
Sinnott was not that bad.
Can't Simon Richman play there?
A far better player than Sinnot!!!
And of course Watmore (I still think right wing his best position), with either Brooke or Mitchley up front
-
I'd prefere Richman in the 7 shirt.
Watmore is more deadlier in the number 9 shirt.
-
I'd prefere Richman in the 7 shirt.
Watmore is more deadlier in the number 9 shirt.
shall we have a poll... :D
-
My team for Tuesday, assuming a full squad minus Lawrie :
Coburn
Densmore Havern Hall Doughty
Richman Rodgers Moult Clee
Watmore Reeves
-
Thats a really strong right flank to be fair :D
-
Same side as phil however I'd have Watmore on right wing and have richman just behind reeves he seemed to do well there against Harrogate
-
That team is easily good enough to make the playoffs. No excuses.
-
According to todays Torygraph Sinnott was Man of the Match on Saturday
-
According to todays Torygraph Sinnott was Man of the Match on Saturday
there is a reason why some people watch football and pay to get in and other people manage teams and get paid to do it.
-
My team for Tuesday, assuming a full squad minus Lawrie :
Coburn
Densmore Havern Hall Doughty
Richman Rodgers Moult Clee
Watmore Reeves
agree with that but would like to see
Coburn
Havern Hall Leather
Rodgers
Densmore Richman moult Doughty
Watmore Reeves
-
Wot, no Nicky ? ? ?
-
Returning to the original topic of this thread, I note that Lee Sinnott was present to witness his son's debut for Huddersfield Town last Saturday:
http://www.examiner.co.uk/huddersfield-town-fc/huddersfield-town-news/2013/01/28/jordan-sinnott-delighted-by-huddersfield-town-debut-86081-32690696/ (http://www.examiner.co.uk/huddersfield-town-fc/huddersfield-town-news/2013/01/28/jordan-sinnott-delighted-by-huddersfield-town-debut-86081-32690696/)
Plus the match was also refereed by our old friend and Altrincham FC supporter, Anthony Taylor.