Why do we need to do lots of hypothetical workings?
If we'd have had McGivern as a partner from the start then we might have made the playoffs regardless of the state of the midfield or defence.
If we'd have unearthed the right defensive pairings we could have won lots of games one nil without Reeves. It's all pie in the sky.
To say we would have been relegated is nonsense and someone with your level of non league knowledge knows it really, you've just become clouded with a hatred of the current manager.
35 points without Reeves
if you can not see the problem then it not my judgement clouded
McGivern a better partner than Redshaw? he only had one good game and that was yesterday
The problem is that we have had a error prone defence all season and little protection for it from the midfield.
Signings in those areas have either failed to live up to expectation or have been not been right for the job.
This has to be improved from the start of next season.
Just to confirm what was being hinted at about me yesterday, and what you were referring to before about "happy clappers" I'm as disappointed as anyone about how the season has panned out.
It depends on how you want to look at things. I'd prefer to say we missed the playoffs by say 8 points, you prefer to say we were 15 points off relegation. Either way we missed our target this season.
I just don't think that ripping it all up and starting again is the answer.